re:constitution
2024/ 2025

Etienne Hanelt

Mobility Phase: HUN-REN Centre for Social Sciences, Budapest | Political Capital, Budapest

Castles of Illiberal Thought and Mercenary Thinkers: Academic Legitimation of Authoritarian Politics in Hungary

Etienne Hanelt is a political scientist interested in democratic backsliding, European responses to the rule of law crisis in EU Member States and judicial politics. He holds a DPhil from the University of Oxford, where he wrote a thesis titled ‘Supranational Tug of War: Overcoming the European Union’s Authoritarian Equilibrium’. There, he examined the interplay between democratic backsliding in Hungary and Poland, and elite decision-making on the rule of law in the European Union. Since 2021, he has worked at the Judicial Studies Institute of Masaryk University (Czech Republic), conducting qualitative research on informal judicial institutions and supranational actors' influence on democracy in EU Member States as part of the ERC-funded INFINITY project. He currently works on Verfassungsblog’s Judicial Resilience Project, which employs scenario analysis to study the vulnerability of the German judiciary against authoritarian-populist actors.

Castles of Illiberal Thought and Mercenary Thinkers: Academic Legitimation of Authoritarian Politics in Hungary

Many authoritarian regimes engage in image management domestically as well as abroad. This is also true for Hungary’s competitive authoritarian government under Fidesz. Its methods include propaganda and misinformation, besides far right and authoritarian networking. In its effort to manage its image, the Hungarian government has not spared academic institutions. Not only has Orbán expelled the Central European University from Budapest and tightened political control over state universities, but it has heavily promoted its own academic institutions and think tanks. Their role, however, remains an under-researched topic. Academic research in these institutions is neither free nor open-ended but is motivated and directed to support the government’s agenda by normalising and legitimating its positions. Yet we know very little about these institutions, who they are, how they work, or with what methods they co-opt academics. Their presence introduces problems for scholars: should they interact with mercenary thinkers in publications and conferences? Working with a Hungarian academic institution, research will conducted into this illiberal academic sector. In the second part of my fellowship, a stakeholder engagement strategy to diffuse the findings of the study will be developed in cooperation with a think tank.